Whitman Pioneer

Friday, March 12th, 2010

Subtlety lacks in conceptual ‘Thinking of You’

The Critic / By Becquer Medak-Seguin / May 2, 2009

Sean Day, Obreanna McReynolds, and Jessie Neill’s ‘Thinking of You,’ a short film about a stalker’s stalker, presents a profound shift in style from the insert’s first film ‘EmPlosive.’ Whereas the latter is a technologically-savvy, artistic attempt at at short film, the former is a plot-driven, ironic attempt.

The film introduces us to its voyeuristic protagonist, who relies on a camera and a hair ribbon to propel his adventure, while he is at home in a secret room. The room contains a display where he keeps her paraphernalia, including pictures, sticky notes, and cards.

His pursuit of the girl begins in the following scene when he sees her walking down a sidewalk. She, perhaps purposefully, drops a blue ribbon that he immediately finds. The ribbon seems to perpetuate his stalkerish pursuit, which continues throughout the day: he watches her play football, eat, and leave her house on a bike. Remembering that her ribbon is still in his pocket, the stalker-protagonist decides to chase after (literally) his viewing object in order to return the ribbon she dropped, ultimately, giving him an excuse to talk to her.

Not much is exchanged between the two and they both go home. The films final scene is endowed with a somewhat unexpected twist ending. She is, indeed, a stalker as well. Someone else’s stalker, but a stalker nonetheless.

Cute and clever, this film is about how everyone is someone else’s something. We are, apparently, all interconnected and can share each of our petty vices with those whom we least expect. The stalker, stalks a stalker, who stalks another stalker, ad infinitum. Point taken.

So, does that mean we’re all practically the same?

The film lacks a reliable cinematography and screenplay that, for a topic as pervasive as voyeurism, should have been much subtler than it was. Facebook, Twitter, or any of a number of voyeuristic portholes could have replaced the all-to-cliché dropping of the ribbon. The act of stalking itself has morphed in to a subtle, uncontrollable, and, at times, unintentional act that the film failed to represent; stalking with a camera is so nineteen nineties. A lack of believability also hindered the film: stalkers don’t ever try to impress by striking a Heisman pose.

On the up side, the guitar score was nice.

Reel Score: 4 (out of 10)

The short film ‘Thinking of You’ (2009), directed by Sean Day, Obreanna McReynolds, and Jessie Neill, is 4 minutes long and can be found in the DVD insert of volume 22 of ‘blue moon.’

Share this article
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Subtlety lacks in conceptual ‘Thinking of You’ was published on May 2, 2009 in The Critic and tagged with ,

About Becquer Medak-Seguin

Becquer Medak-Seguin, a senior Spanish Literatures and Cultures major and Latin American Studies minor, is a culture critic for the Whitman Pioneer. He is also a columnist for the International Affairs Journal at UC Davis, an academic online and print journal, where he writes on contemporary Latin American affairs. He has written for the Anchorage Daily News and was editor-in-chief of the student newspaper at Alaska Pacific University.

Speak your mind

Tell us what you're thinking…
and if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

Login with Facebook

If you have a Facebook account and want to login with that information just click the Facebook Connect button below

Disclaimer

Please note we do not allow the publication of any defammatory or offensive comments. You are responsible for your own words, and may be held accountable for them should any individuals choose to pursue action against you. No personal information about commentors will be distributed, except when in violation of this policy.

Whitman College Pioneer on Facebook

Popular this week

Recent comments

  • Jennifer: Ooh, yes, there are songs on it that I’m really not sure about yet but I completely won’t be...
  • Russ: BOOM L. Curtis nails it
  • setry: “When his opponent did win the elections, Ravalomanana contested the results and refused to leave...
  • Heather Nichols-Haining: http://allafrica.com/stories/2 00903270149.html http://www.npr.org/template...
  • Heather Nichols-Haining: I agree – Rajoelina certainly didn’t do the country a favor by instigating near...

All content is the copyright of the Whitman College Pioneer.
Staff Login